We use cookies to improve your experience on our platform. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in our marketing efforts.
Cookies required for basic website functionality.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies that help understand the performance of the website, how users interact with it and to identify bugs.
How is Zeffy free?
How is Zeffy free?
Zeffy relies entirely on optional contributions from donors. At the payment confirmation step - we ask donors to leave an optional contribution to Zeffy.
Mid-level donors represent a unique and valuable opportunity for nonprofits to strengthen their support base. Falling between first-time contributors and major donors, this group can make a significant impact when engaged thoughtfully.
Mid-level donors typically contribute 40-50% of nonprofit revenue, making them a critical but often underutilized donor segment. By focusing on their potential as loyal supporters, you can build meaningful relationships, bridging the gap between smaller and larger donations.
In this guide, we will walk you through essential steps to craft a mid-level donor strategy that builds the sustainable funding foundation your organization needs for long-term impact.
Mid-level donors are those who contribute more than average donors but less than major donors. While exact donation ranges can vary by organization, mid-level giving typically falls between $1,000 and $10,000 annually.
These donors typically demonstrate a stronger commitment to the cause, often donating regularly and engaging more deeply with the nonprofit’s mission.
Prioritizing mid-level donors helps nonprofits build a reliable base with the potential to grow into major donors over time.
How to identify mid-level donors?
Key tools to use
1. Donor databases
A donor database is your primary tool for tracking donation amounts, frequency, and donor engagement. Use it to create clear segments based on giving levels and identify donors who consistently give higher-than-average amounts.
Track donors who consistently respond to your mail appeals with above-average gifts.
These responsive supporters often demonstrate a higher commitment to your cause. Their willingness to act on physical mailings indicates engagement that extends beyond digital interactions, making them prime candidates for mid-level donor programs.
3. Engagement tracking tools
Use email marketing platforms (like Mailchimp or Constant Contact) to see which donors open your emails, click on links, or respond to surveys. These insights help you identify highly engaged supporters.
To understand how people interact with your website more broadly, tools like Google Analytics can show trends in page views, time spent on content, and traffic sources. While they don’t track individual users, they provide valuable context for improving the donor journey overall.
4. Peer recommendations from board members or staff
Encourage board members or staff who regularly interact with donors to highlight individuals who show strong interest in your mission. Sometimes, personal observations can identify mid-level donor potential that data alone might miss.
Key behavioral indicators
1. Consistent giving
Look for donors who maintain a consistent giving schedule - whether monthly, quarterly, or annually - over consecutive periods. This predictable pattern of support signals a deeper commitment and financial planning around your cause.
2. Gradual increase in donations
Donors who steadily increase their contributions, even in small increments, demonstrate a growing commitment to your organization and are excellent candidates for a mid-level program.
3. High engagement beyond donations
Supporters who actively attend events, respond to surveys, or engage with your emails and updates are more invested in your mission. With the right encouragement, these individuals are likely to move into mid-level giving.
4. Unsolicited larger gifts
Donors who make one-time contributions significantly higher than your average gift, without prompting, might already have the capacity and interest to give more. These individuals are strong candidates for more personalized engagement.
5. Proactive communication
Donors who reach out to ask about specific programs, projects, or the impact of their donations are often more engaged. This behavior suggests they are committed to your mission and may be willing to take a more active role in supporting it.
How to build a mid-level donor profile?
1. Demographic information
Collect basic details such as age range, geographic location, and employment status. These factors can provide context about their financial capacity and the types of causes they are most likely to support.
2. Giving patterns
To identify trends and predict future giving behavior, analyze how often the donors give, their average donation amount, and the channels they use (e.g., online, direct mail, or events).
3. Program interests
Review which programs or projects mid-level donors consistently support.
For example, donors who favor educational initiatives may be more inclined to fund scholarships or mentorship programs. Knowing their interests allows you to craft appeals that resonate with their values.
4. Engagement history
Track how donors interact with your organization, such as attending events, opening emails, or following your social media. Donors with high engagement levels often show greater loyalty and are more likely to increase their contributions.
Some donors prefer digital updates, while others value personal calls or mailed reports. Understanding these preferences allows you to communicate in ways that make donors feel appreciated and respected.
Mid-level donors contribute 40-50% of nonprofit revenue, forming the financial backbone of many organizations. This substantial segment bridges the gap between smaller donations and major gifts, providing the consistent support needed for program planning and operational stability.
Their reliable giving reduces dependence on unpredictable one-time donations and creates a more sustainable funding model.
2. Pathway to major contributions
Mid-level donors are often on the path to becoming major donors; this progression is a key part of donor stewardship.
By engaging with them effectively through a mid-level donor program, nonprofits can nurture relationships that may lead to larger gifts over time.
3. Reliable and sustained giving
Unlike occasional contributors, mid-level donors are more likely to donate regularly, whether through annual giving or other consistent channels. Relying on these donors ensures that nonprofits have steady support to sustain their operations and programs.
4. Strengthens long-term relationships
A mid-level donor program allows nonprofits to focus on building meaningful, long-term relationships. These donors are often invested in the organization’s mission and appreciate personalized engagement. Retaining them not only strengthens the overall donor base but also creates advocates who may encourage others to contribute.
Without a structured program, mid-level donors may feel overlooked, causing them to reduce their contributions or disengage entirely. This impacts financial support and limits the organization’s ability to develop future major donors.
Key strategies to cultivate, engage, and retain mid-level donors
1. Cultivation strategies to build connections
Personalized communication
All types and levels of donors prefer personalized communication. Consider reaching out with thank-you notes, emails, or phone calls that acknowledge their individual contributions and highlight the impact of their support.
Invite donors into the process
Ask mid-level donors for their feedback through surveys or one-on-one conversations. Giving them a chance to share their thoughts can make them feel valued and more connected to your mission, increasing their commitment.
Segment appeals based on giving history
Use donor data to create appeals tailored to each donor’s giving history. For example, if a donor has consistently supported education initiatives, mention how their contributions have impacted similar programs and invite them to support an upcoming project in that area.
A personalized approach like this reinforces their connection to your mission and encourages ongoing support.
Provide unique experiences, like behind-the-scenes tours of your programs, or invite them to meet your leadership team. Exclusive experiences help mid-level donors feel more involved and valued.
2. Engagement strategies to keep donors involved
Create donor recognition opportunities
Acknowledge mid-level donors by including their names in annual reports, event programs, or donor walls. Recognizing their contributions publicly can boost their sense of pride and belonging.
Organize smaller gatherings specifically for mid-level donors, such as donor appreciation dinners or exclusive “insider” briefings about upcoming projects, as personalized interactions help deepen connections.
Use multi-channel outreach
Engage donors through various channels, including direct mail, email, social media, and phone calls. Make sure your messaging is consistent across channels, and adapt your content to match the strengths of each platform.
Use storytelling to connect emotionally and keep donors engaged, whether through email, social media, or direct mail.
Send mid-level donors targeted updates like impact reports, success stories, or videos directly from beneficiaries. Highlight how their contributions specifically led your organization to make a difference.
Offer leadership opportunities
Consider inviting mid-level donors to join advisory boards, planning committees, or other leadership roles to highlight their importance to your organization while encouraging greater involvement.
3. Retention strategies for building loyalty
Acknowledge milestones personally
Highlight key moments in your relationship with mid-level donors, such as the anniversary of their first gift or a significant increase in their giving level. For these occasions, send a personalized acknowledgment, such as a heartfelt note or a phone call from a senior team member.
Introduce tiered membership programs
Offer a structured membership program exclusively for mid-level donors, designed to reflect their individual contributions. Include meaningful perks like behind-the-scenes updates on programs they’ve supported or invitations to donor-only events.
Dedicate an annual event to mid-level donors, highlighting their collective impact over the year.
Use engaging visuals like project photos or short videos to share success stories and progress updates. Incorporate live testimonials from beneficiaries or program leaders to create a memorable and authentic experience that reinforces their value.
Keep donors informed regularly
Maintain consistent communication by providing monthly and yearly updates, such as newsletters or brief project updates. Share highlights like new initiatives or insights into ongoing programs to keep donors involved in your work and show that their support matters year-round, not just during campaigns.
Offer legacy options
Introduce long-term giving opportunities to mid-level donors who have shown a deep commitment to your mission. Provide information on planned giving options like naming your organization in their will or establishing a fund for a specific cause.
4. Advanced strategies for mid-level donors
Set giving challenges or matches
Encourage mid-level donors to participate in unique giving challenges, such as time-limited match campaigns or milestone goals. For example, donors can be invited to fund a specific project collectively, with updates on how close they are to reaching the target.
Communicate how their leadership in these efforts inspires other supporters, emphasizing their crucial role in creating large-scale impact.
Host webinars on topics that resonate with mid-level donors, such as industry insights, challenges your organization is addressing, or emerging trends related to your mission.
Invite guest speakers, such as subject-matter experts, beneficiaries, nonprofit leaders, or passionate advocates, to share their perspectives.
Create peer networking opportunities
Organize private in-person or virtual meet-ups for mid-level donors to network and discuss shared goals. Building a donor community fosters loyalty and shared purpose.
Introduce strategic giving plans
Work with mid-level donors to create personalized giving plans, such as multi-year pledges or contributions tied to specific milestones. It is an approach to show trust and secure consistent donor support over time.
Final thoughts on mid-level donor strategy
Mid-level donors represent almost half of a nonprofit’s revenue, and these dedicated supporters provide the consistent support that fuels your mission day after day.
A well-crafted mid-level donor strategy transforms occasional supporters into passionate advocates whose growing commitments strengthen your nonprofit. Such an approach also helps naturally develop this support into major gift opportunities for the future.
The challenge many nonprofits face isn't identifying these valuable supporters, but finding efficient ways to nurture these relationships without increasing administrative overhead. This is where smart technology can make all the difference.
By streamlining these processes, Zeffy helps nonprofits focus on building personal connections with mid-level donors while ensuring their support is managed efficiently.
Look for signs like a consistent increase in their donation amounts, expressed interest in supporting larger initiatives, or direct inquiries about deeper involvement. These behaviors indicate that a donor may be ready to move into a major gift portfolio with the right engagement and opportunities.
Yes, digital campaigns can target mid-level donors by using segmented email lists or personalized landing pages. Highlight projects that match their interests and include specific giving options, such as funding milestones or matching opportunities, to align with their capacity.
Focus on metrics like donor retention rate, average gift size growth, and the number of mid-level donors transitioning to major giving. Tracking these key performance indicators ensures your strategy is both effective and adaptable over time.
Start with a personalized message acknowledging their past support and sharing updates about programs they helped fund. Offer a unique way to reconnect, such as an invitation to a donor appreciation event or a direct conversation about how their contributions made an impact.
9 Effective Strategies for Major Donor Fundraising [2024 Guide]
Cultivate donors who can make substantial gifts to fuel your nonprofit's growth. Learn 9 major donor strategies to identify, engage, and secure contributions.
