We use cookies to improve your experience on our platform. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in our marketing efforts.
Cookies required for basic website functionality.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies that help understand the performance of the website, how users interact with it and to identify bugs.
How is Zeffy free?
How is Zeffy free?
Zeffy relies entirely on optional contributions from donors. At the payment confirmation step - we ask donors to leave an optional contribution to Zeffy.
Every nonprofit organization faces risks that can disrupt its work, such as financial mismanagement, compliance issues, or unexpected crises. These disruptions can dent your mission and impact your reputation without a proper risk management plan.
Effective nonprofit risk management helps you identify, assess, and control risks to protect your organization and guard its missions.
In this guide, we will provide practical steps to manage risks smartly so your nonprofit can stay resilient to all obstructions.
Strategic risk management forms the backbone of sustainable nonprofit operations, enabling organizations to fulfill their missions while protecting their resources, reputation, and relationships.
A well-designed risk management approach doesn't just prevent problems—it creates opportunities for growth and innovation.
Key benefits of effective risk management include:
Enhanced mission impact: By identifying and addressing potential obstacles early, your nonprofit can focus more resources on serving beneficiaries and less on crisis management.
Stronger stakeholder trust: Demonstrating proactive risk management builds confidence among donors, volunteers, and community partners.
Improved resource allocation: Understanding your risk landscape helps prioritize investments in areas that matter most to your mission.
Greater organizational resilience: Well-prepared nonprofits can adapt quickly to challenges and maintain service continuity during unexpected events.
Better decision-making: Data-driven risk assessment provides valuable insights for strategic planning and program development.
These benefits create a stronger foundation for your nonprofit's long-term success and community impact.
4 best practices of an effective nonprofit risk management strategy
1. Identifying risks
The first step in building a risk management strategy for your nonprofit is identifying concerns specific to your organization. Analyze every aspect of your operations to pinpoint vulnerable areas.
The leadership team, staff, and board members can offer insights into critical and recurring risks. With their help, review your nonprofit’s activities, finances, and programs to spot risks. For example, look for gaps in processes, such as donor solicitation, donor management, and event organization.
Reviewing past incidents can help predict future vulnerabilities more accurately. Seek regular feedback from stakeholders like volunteers, donors, and community members.
2. Assessing, analyzing, and prioritizing risks
Use tools such as a nonprofit risk assessment matrix to decide which risks to handle first. Two simple questions help you prioritize management:
How likely is the risk to happen?
How much harm could it cause?
More likely and severe risks – like data breaches exposing sensitive donor information – should be addressed immediately. Others of lesser probability or impact, such as delays in social media posting, can simply be monitored and addressed as they occur.
Think about the inherent risks of your nonprofit organization, too. For example, if your nonprofit depends on one large donor for most of its funding, the risks associated with losing that donor loom large. Address such concerns on priority to prevent rippling impacts on volunteer morale, mission promises, and donor trust.
3. Risk mitigation and control
Once nonprofits know which risks to focus on, the next step is to manage and reduce them by coordinating with the team and deciding on a comprehensive risk management strategy.
Start by planning whether the concern is organization-wide or if specific teams can resolve it. Set up SOPs (standard operating procedures) highlighting the role and timeline for each member involved in the risk management process.
Next, the procedures for internal controls to protect finances and operations should be put down. For example, having two people approve large expenses can prevent fraud. Supplement your team's efforts with secure nonprofit accounting software to protect donor information and track financial transactions more accurately.
Consider conducting third-party audits to ensure legal compliance for tax-exempt status and to avoid fines.
4. Monitoring and reviewing risks
Regularly checking the efficiency of your risk management strategies helps you evolve your plans as you grow and take up new initiatives. To stay ahead of potential risks and adapt to the changing nonprofit trends, connect frequently with your risk management team and check performance analytics.
Self-evaluations also help understand the impact of current policies and alert you to any gaps before they become major issues.
For example, reviewing financial processes and data security practices can show if your privacy encryptions are strengthening. Simpler risks like skill gaps in the team and their impacts can also be mitigated through regular reviews.
7 common types of nonprofit risks to avoid
1. Data breaches and cybersecurity risks
Nonprofits often store sensitive donor information, making them a target for cyberattacks.
As reliance on digital platforms grows, risks like phishing and ransomware can lead to donor data leaks and transaction fraud. Investing in a secure system and regular training for your team can help prevent these issues.
2. Financial instability
Economic downturns or shifts in donor priorities can reduce funding. Nonprofits that depend on limited funding sources, such as a single grant or a few major donors, are especially vulnerable. A diversified funding strategy is essential to manage this financial risk.
Changing laws and stricter regulations pose challenges for nonprofits, especially regarding tax-exempt status or reporting requirements. Failing to comply can result in fines, loss of status, and breach of donor faith. Regular legal reviews ensure nonprofits stay compliant.
Due to competition with for-profit businesses, attracting and retaining skilled employees has become harder for nonprofits. High turnover, poor training, and staff burnout can make it harder for nonprofits to operate.
Consider offering fair benefits and self-paced training programs to reduce these employee discomforts and keep teams strong.
5. Reputational damage
Errors like miscommunication, the use of discriminatory terms, and the addition of hidden charges on donations can dent your nonprofit’s reputation and weaken donor relations. Strong donor communication strategies and clear internal policies can help manage and reduce these risks.
6. Strategic risks in technology adoption
Technology can improve how nonprofits work, but using outdated tools or implementing new systems poorly can cause more harm than benefit. Providing training and ensuring new tools are secure and work smoothly can avoid these problems.
Natural disasters and climate change create challenges for nonprofits, especially those working in disaster relief or high-risk areas. Create contingency plans, arrange additional resources, train a backup team to avoid losses, and lastly, strengthen your team’s stress management capabilities regularly.
Download our free risk management checklist for nonprofits
Using automation, RiskWatch improves the speed and accuracy of risk assessments and documentation. Its real-time dashboards help you track all activities and get early alerts for potential financial or engagement risks.
2. LogicManager
LogicManager is designed to track and manage all kinds of financial risks across your organization. It lets you gather all your risk-related data in one place and helps you stay prepared for audits or unexpected challenges.
3. Ostendio
Ostendio offers an integrated security and risk management platform designed to strengthen business operations and supply chains. It enables organizations to build, operate, and showcase their entire security program on a single platform. Some features include real-time compliance task management, vendor risk assessments, and collaborative audit capabilities.
4. ZenGRC
ZenGRC protects nonprofits from legal risks by providing them with a central platform to track compliance with NPO laws. It organizes important documents, monitors tasks to ensure nothing is missed, and simplifies audits by keeping everything in one place.
5. Resolver
Resolver provides a comprehensive risk intelligence platform that gathers all risk data, analyzes it in context, and details the true business impact of each risk. It allows collaboration across the enterprise for teams to understand their risks and control effectiveness fully.
6. Riskonnect
Riskonnect offers a unified platform to manage risk and compliance across an organization. It provides real-time data and analytics, enabling businesses to make informed decisions quickly. The platform offers risk visibility, streamlined compliance, and reporting tools to track progress and identify trends.
Final thoughts on nonprofit risk management
Managing risks is essential for nonprofits to protect their mission, resources, and reputation.
While it’s impossible to eliminate every risk, having a clear strategy ensures you can handle challenges effectively and stay focused on your goals. Regular reviews, clear policies, and a proactive approach help organizations stay ahead of emerging challenges.
Zeffy’s 100% free fundraising platform can support your efforts by securely handling donor payments and protecting sensitive data. By using trusted solutions, your nonprofit can stay focused on making a difference while minimizing potential risks.
One big risk nonprofits sometimes miss is losing important information when staff or key volunteers leave. It can be hard to keep things running smoothly if they don't have clear records of how things work, like processes, programs, and policies.
To avoid this, nonprofits should update their internal manuals regularly and have plans in place for when someone leaves. By doing this, your nonprofit can keep things consistent and high-quality even with changes.
Misinformation about a nonprofit can spread quickly and hurt its reputation. To stop this, nonprofits need to watch what is being said about them online and correct any wrong information immediately.
They should have a plan in place for when people misunderstand or say things that aren't true. This plan includes choosing a person to talk to the public and making sure the messages shared are clear and consistent.
When a leader in a nonprofit leaves suddenly, it can cause problems with how things are run. To protect against this, nonprofits should have a plan for what happens when someone in charge leaves.
This plan should include clear steps for the transition, like training other team members to take on the leader's duties while a new leader is found. This helps keep the nonprofit running smoothly and reduces the risk of confusion during the change.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Keep reading :
Nonprofit software
Top 18 Nonprofit Management Software Solutions
Find the best nonprofit management software solutions for 2024. Enhance your organization's efficiency and effectiveness with these 18 top-rated platforms.
Donor Management Software: 9 Best Options for Small Nonprofits in 2025
Compare the top donor management software options for small nonprofits — including Zeffy, Kindful, Classy, and more — and find the best free platform for your nonprofit.
